5. “Bull In The Heather” – Sonic Youth
(From the album Experimental Jet Set, Trash And No Star)
1994
Sonic Youth’s Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star moves in an interesting artistic direction for the band. On the one hand, the album is more pop-oriented and melodic than their previous work and therefore, at least in one sense, is more accessible. Make no mistake, the songs on Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star are still full of strange detours and unusual choices, but for the most part the album lacks the ear-shredding distortion and long dissonant passages that often made their earlier records less accessible. On the other hand though, Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star also moves the band away from the prevailing alt rock sound of the time. The album is sonically still definitely the work of Sonic Youth, but it also doesn’t widely feature the big riffs and sonic intensity that was dominating alternative rock at the time (and that Sonic Youth themselves played a key role in inspiring). Much of Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star rocks less directly and is more subtle than anything the band had done before. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star is an album that is accessible, but not immediate, and therefore takes a few listens before its hidden hooks and little surprises grab the listener. In other words, it is an album that would appeal to their large and devoted fan base, but probably (purposefully) wouldn’t expand that fan base much with the new legions who had found Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Smashing Pumpkins, and Stone Temple Pilots over the previous few years. The album’s sole single “Bull In The Heather” illustrates the sound of the album well. “Bull In The Heather” is a crafty and catchy song that feels like it is slowly building up to an angsty climax; only that climax never comes. Kim Gordon’s vocals build up in tension and angst, but when the moment comes for the song to follow the loud-soft-loud 90’s formula and explode into a chorus made for moshing “Bull In The Heather” instead pulls back and leaves that tension largely unresolved. It is a songwriting choice that makes for a more interesting song that moves in unexpected directions, but not for a crossover hit. That said, “Bull In The Heather” was still hook-oriented enough (and Sonic Youth had enough momentum built up from the success of Dirty) that the song hit #52 in the UK and #13 on the US alternative rock chart. This decision to turn their sound inward rather than allowing it to explode out in cathartic blasts of noise like Sonic Youth once would have done can be heard all across Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star. Opening track “Winner’s Blues” is a restless, acoustic number, while “Self-Obsessed and Sexxee” rides its driving groove without ever losing control. Even when the band threatens to lose control, like on “Androgynous Mind” or “Tokyo Eye”, they pull back from total chaos at the last second. In the end, these choices make Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star an incredible listen, but not one designed for mainstream, crossover success even if it seems more accessible at first.
Follow all the posts at the Alternative Reality site: www.alternativealbumsblog.wordpress.com